Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.
Promising reviews: "I have plantar fasciitis and my feet always hurt! It's so rare that I can just put on a pair of shoes and they don't wear my feet into blisters and pain. I walk a lot and needed shoes that could stand miles of walking. These are wonderful and I can put orthotics in with plenty of space and not fitting too tight. It was good to find a shoe that I could use both the orthotics in and the arch felt actually high enough!" —S. Smith
"This is my third pair of Blundstone boots in the span of approximately 15 years. I have always been very pleased. These are perfect boots for traveling — easy off at the airport, light, comfortable and waterproof. Good for most weather conditions, and can be worn with jeans or a suit." —T. Merker
Get them from Amazon for $141.96+ (available in sizes 4–14 and 15 colors).
Promising reviews: "Travel tested and approved — LOVE!! My hairdresser friend recommended these since she’s always on her feet. They were so reasonable so I ordered them for my South Africa honeymoon trip. They were INCREDIBLE!!! My feet never hurt and I walked a ton of miles in them. They also went with a ton of outfits, so I was very happy!!! I highly recommend!" —Leah Gwin Hoefling
"These shoes were recommended as comfortable walking shoes. They absolutely are the best! I bought these shoes to have a stylish, casual shoe for a NYC/DC seven-day tour. I walked an average of 7–8 miles a day even in a downpour. Not a single blister or pain of any kind. If you are searching for stylish, casual, and comfortable, then these are it. Easy on and off, water-resistant, and coordinates with all outfits." —S. Lee
Get them from Amazon for $42.94+ (available in sizes 5–15, including wide options, and 27 styles).
Promising review: "Love my new sandals! Great cushioning and arch support, sporty look, and the adjustable strap is great for the Florida humidity that makes your feet swell when you walk a bit. I found them true to size. I'm usually between an 8 and 8.5 (usually the larger size in athletic shoes) and found the 8 in these to fit well. Got lots of compliments on them my first day wearing them! So comfy!" —Maggie
Get them from Amazon for $125+ (available in sizes 5–10 and five styles).
Promising review: "I bought these for travel after seeing them recommended on multiple travel sites. Although the manufacturer says the boots are waterproofed, I did spray them with a suede protectant. I recently returned from a trip to Barcelona where I wore these all day for several days. We walked about six miles a day, and I had no discomfort. (They’re significantly more comfortable than the pair of Cole Haan Chelsea boots that they were bought to replace.) It rained pretty heavily one day, and I found these to be completely waterproof. What’s more, the rain did not seem to affect the boots at all; they still look brand new. I plan to take them with me to London and Paris next month. They also look great for work with tights. All-around great shoe. I’m very pleased with the purchase and would highly recommend them." —HEO1121
Get them from Amazon for $106.01+ (available in sizes 6–12, including wide options, and nine styles).
Promising review: "I took these boots to a trip to NYC, I walked all day and they did not cause any blister or extra tiredness. They are comfortable, easy to put on especially at airport security. They are so trendy and the platform is not tiring at all. They don’t claim to be waterproof but it rained a lot and my feet never got wet. I would definitely recommend these. ❤️" —Sandra
Get them from Amazon for $15.59+ (available in sizes 5–13 and 14 styles).
Promising review: "I bought these sandals before a three-week trip in Europe; I didn't want to pay for Birks but did want something in similar style with good arch support. I was a little skeptical about the low price, but gave them a shot...and they were the MOST comfortable sandals I've ever owned. I walked over 120 miles in them in three weeks on our trip and never once had foot pain. They broke in so quickly and were very supportive from the get go — and still are! Highly recommend." —Han Lin
Get them from Amazon for $217.99+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide options, and 21 styles).
Promising review: "I initially bought these shoes to look cute for pictures in my outfits, but was shocked to realize how comfortable they actually were! I wore these sandals throughout a walking tour of Chicago AND to the airport, without any blisters or sores. I highly recommend this product — it's so rare to find affordable cute AND comfy sandals." —Hayles
Get them from Amazon for $44.79+ (available in sizes 5.5–10 and four styles).
They're also a popular pick with people who have jobs where waterproof shoes come in handy (like working at a restaurant or dog groomers).
Promising review: "I absolutely love these shoes! I originally bought them for a trip to Washington D.C where it was going to rain most of the time. I have Hunter rain boots, but knew we would be walking a lot and didn't want to be 'weighed down' on the trip. I was four months pregnant and wore these for two of the days where we walked over 9 miles each day (ugh!) and these were SOO COMFORTABLE! My feet didn't have any blisters or sore spots (which I am very prone to) and handled the rain/puddles like a champ! I love that they looked like normal shoes, but wiped clean with a baby wipe! Totally surprised by the comfort and quality of these rain shoes. I now use them when in the garden or anytime it rains! Also, the inside sole of the shoe comes out pretty easily, which annoyed me at first until I wanted to wash it to keep the inside smelling fresh — so now it's a bonus! BUY THESE!" —AmazonFamily
Get them from Amazon for $33.99+ (available in sizes 5.5–11, low-top and high-top options and four colors).
Promising review: "I went on a muddy hike today to break these in. First they are so comfortable and have nice toe room. I stepped in a deep muddy puddle and when I took my foot out, the mud and water just ran off. They were still clean! My husband did not have waterproof shoes and his feet were wet. By the time we finished, mine were bone dry. They are wonderful hiking boots, very comfortable, sturdy and super stylish too! I can’t wait to see where the bad girls will take me." —Samantha
Get them from Amazon for $56.16+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide options, and 16 styles). You can find a similar men's version here.
Prime members: You can try before you buy!
Promising reviews: "These are my favorite. As a Southern Californian, I wear flip-flops year-round. The last pair of Sanuk Yoga Mat flip-flops I bought lasted through almost three years of constant wear (they were basically the only shoes I wore for three years, so I'm serious when I say constant). They're comfortable enough to wear for a day at Disneyland, even with arthritic joints." —beth
"I've been wearing Sanuks for about five years now and they are hands-down the best flip-flops I've ever owned. I usually live in them from the time the snow melts until it starts falling again. They are sturdy, comfortable, and lightweight. The yoga mat base is unbelievably comfortable, and stays comfortable even with regular use. The strap is made of cloth and a soft leather/cloth combination. Honestly once you wear these you'll never go to another Old Navy $1 flip-flop day. The last point I want to make about these flip-flops is that they are great for travel. I wore them for nearly three weeks while backpacking in Europe and my feet did not blister or peel and the lightweight material was great for reducing weight while traveling." —Liz
Get them from Amazon for $19.95+ (available in sizes 5–11, with some wide options, and 16 styles).
If you're a half-size, several reviewers recommend ordering up (so a 9 if you're an 8.5, etc.).
Promising review: "I LOVE these sandals!!! I bought them originally for some summer travels — I wanted something comfortable and versatile that I could wear with everything. They were supportive enough with non-slip grip to wear on the cliff walk in Newport, RI. I’ve had them for about a month now and I’ve continued to wear them almost everyday, even to amusement park on the roller coasters. So glad I bought them!" —Sheena Faye
Get them from Amazon for $26.97+ (available in sizes 5–11 and five styles).
Miuccia Studio is based in Indonesia and specializes in the *dreamiest* handmade shoes and bags.
Promising review: "Love love love these!! I’ve been looking for the perfect pair of mules for months, I’m so happy I ordered these. They go with everything and super comfy. Shipping was right on time if not a little early." —Stacie Carlson
Get them from Miuccia Studio on Etsy for $76.50 (originally $90; available in European sizes 36–43 and six colors).
Promising review: "Absolutely love these boots! I needed a pair of sturdy hiking boots that looked cute, would last a long time, were water resistant, and would wipe off easily after a muddy day. I wore these for roughly two miles of hiking and maybe two miles of walking to break them in before wearing them for a nine mile hike in the Appalachians. I was so impressed with how comfortable they were, just the right amount of grip, they were warm, and they kept my feet dry and my ankles supported. 10/10 I would buy these again and will definitely be buying a second pair once the first pair is worn out." —Emma
Get them from Amazon for $74.91+ (available in sizes 5–11 and three colors).
Psst: They're also machine-washable.
Promising reviews: "Love, love, love! I have a VERY difficult time finding sandals that fit my narrow foot. These are the most comfortable sandals I've ever owned. I can tighten them to fit my feet and walk for hours. My first pair went to Italy and Greece with me, and it's the only shoe I wore the entire three-week trip. I have started to buy in other colors and currently own three pairs." —Robin A. Laehn
"I wore these for 10 straight hours with over six miles of walking right out of the box and had zero foot pain. I’m 61, and my feet are often achy. I used to wear thong sandals but can’t stand anything between my toes anymore so decided to try these. Now, I want them in every color. They fit true to size and have great arch support. We had to walk down an extremely steep hill, and they had plenty of traction to keep me from slipping." —EGC
Get them from Amazon for $35.90+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide fits, and 10 styles).
Promising review: "I bought these for a trip to Turkey and Greece. I didn’t have any break in time, but didn’t need any. They were as comfortable as slippers, but offer support for miles of daily walking. I’ll be buying more." —Mary
Get them from Allbirds for $98 (available in sizes 5–11 and 26 styles).
Birdies is a woman-founded company that originally created a comfortable and stylish slipper that could be worn at home while hosting parties. But they quickly realized the shoes were too good to *just* be worn inside and created a do-it-all flat, combining the support of a sneaker with the softness of a slipper.
Promising reviews: "Brought these on a trip to Tokyo where I needed a pair of dressier flats. Day three wearing them — so far no foot pain; around 10,000 steps per day so far for context." —Lauren S.
"These shoes are so cute and comfy! I bought them for a work trip and they were the best. I walked all over NYC in them and my feet never hurt!" —Julianne G.
Get them from Birdies for $65+ (available in sizes 5–12 and 34 styles).
Promising review: "We were a few days out from our Canadian and Alaskan vacation when I decided to purchase these shoes. They arrived on time as stated (thanks Amazon Prime). I was very skeptical about throwing a brand new pair of shoes in the suitcase when I hadn’t even worn them yet. I would later find out that my husband thought the same. I wore them for the first time on our first full day in Vancouver, BC, with absolutely no problems. I was amazed and in love!! For those with problem toes, note that I am less than one year out after having hammer toe surgery on both feet. Needless to say, I just ordered a second pair." —Leisa Smith
Get them from Amazon for $33.28+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide and narrow fits, and two styles).
Promising reviews: "I walked around Epcot for 12 hours in these flip-flops. Not a single sore. So comfortable! Highly recommended." —tina roya
"These are AMAZING. The only flip-flops I’ve ever owned that I can literally walk all day in comfortably! Took them on an eight-day beach vacation and averaged 5.5 miles per day walking! They stick to your feet firmly — very little 'flopping' lol. I also have a wide foot and have issues finding flip-flops and sandals that my feet won’t spill over the sides of. Amazing shoe. And for a Crocs product, not bad-looking!" —S Doeringsfeld
Get them from Amazon for $24.95+ (available in sizes 4–11 and 14 colors).
Laboo Leather is a family-owned small biz based in Budapest, Hungary, making handmade leather sandals and wallets.
Promising review: "No matter what I’ll write now, it won’t do Botond’s work justice. These sandals are the greatest thing I ever put on my feet — even though I’ve been wearing barefoot shoes for more than 2.5 years. They take the shoe game to the next level. The fit, the flexibility of not only the sole but the entire sandal with all the possible adjustments, the softness of the leather, the comfort, the quality of it altogether. I’ve worn them several times now and I love them so much! Botond was a dream to work with and helped me figure out what I need. I am so satisfied with the entire process, the communication and the final result. Thank you so so much, Botond, I am so grateful for your time, patience and brilliant work. Can’t wait to order again. 15 out of 10 possible points." —sarahkoe
Get them from Laboo Leather on Etsy for $107.30+ (available in EU sizes 35–46 and nine colors or a personalized size for a slightly extra price).
These have the American Podiatric Medical Association Seal of Acceptance, which is granted to products found to promote good foot health!
Prime members: You can try before you buy!
Promising reviews: "Fits awesome! I have plantar fasciitis, heel pain and these sandals are so comfortable and beautiful. I wear them almost every day! I walk 5 miles and my feet are very happy. No pain! The arch support is awesome!" —acdkp1
"I bought the exact same sandals five years ago and wore them all the time including island and European travels. I pretty much wore them out and so I’m thrilled to find the same pair newly available. Yay!" —amaki
Get them from Amazon for $73.75+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide and narrow sizes, and 44 styles).
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.